Charter School Law Ranking and Scorecard 2011

Massachusetts

 

 

 

  Charter Connection
  Charter Laws
  Charter Facts & Stats
  State Resources
  Parent Power
  About CER
  CER Home

[return to map]

[complete report]

LAW

Year Passed

1993; last amended in 2010.

Rank

17th strongest of the nation's 41 charter laws.

Grade

C

GENERAL DATA

 

• Two of the state enrollment restrictions were eliminated or increased in early 2010, but some operational autonomy was lost in negotiations

• State board authorizer consistently approves strong schools

• Impact aid requirement provides disincentives for districts to approve charters

INDEPENDENT OR MULTIPLE AUTHORIZERS - NO

Approval

The State Board of Education authorizes two types of charter schools: Commonwealth charters are those approved directly by the state board; Horace Mann charters are normally conversion schools approved by the school board and teachers union before state approval.

Appeal

None.

NUMBER OF SCHOOLS ALLOWED

Cap

Yes. Two types of caps. 72 Commonwealth charters and 48 Horace Mann charters allowed. 9 percent cap on the total district spending for Commonwealth charters. In the lowest-scoring districts, this cap is increased to 12 percent and then incrementally by 1 percent each year until the cap reaches 18 percent.

OPERATIONAL AUTONOMY

State

Yes. There is no blanket waiver but the law gives schools a wide range of autonomy. New restrictions mandating enrollment percentages for certain student categories (ELL, at-risk, etc.) and new rules on funding reserves. Virtual schools not allowed.Management contracts with ESPs are not restricted.

Local

Yes. Commonwealth charters are free from district rules governing operations and funding. Horace Mann schools get their oversight and budgets from the district.

Teacher Freedom

Yes for Commonwealth charters. Teachers not covered by district bargaining agreement. No for Horace Mann charters. A charter school must recognize a teachers union as the exclusive collective bargaining unit for all teachers if 60 percent of teachers are members of that unit. Charter schools must participate in the state's retirement system.

EQUITY

Student Funding

• 100 percent of state and district operations funding is required to follow the student, but the formula created reflects only the average per pupil cost of each district where the charter school receives students.

• Impact aid reimbursements “reward” districts that lose students—100 percent in the first year, 60 percent the next year, and 40 percent the following year.

• Funds pass from state to school, minus deductions from state aid to affected districts.

"The commonwealth shall pay a tuition amount to the charter school, which shall be the sum of the tuition amounts calculated separately for each district sending students to the charter school. Tuition amounts for each sending district shall be calculated by the department of education using the formula set forth herein, to reflect, as much as practicable, the actual per pupil spending amount that would be expended in the district if the students attended the district schools." [MA Gen Law 89(nn)]

Facilities Funding

Yes. Charters receive a per pupil capital needs allowance, which was $893 per pupil in FY 2009. [MA Gen Law 89(nn)]

The Center for Education Reform
910 Seventeenth Street, NW, Suite 1120 Washington, DC 20006
(tel) 800-520-2118 301-986-8088 (fax) 301-986-1826
 
cer@edreform.com www.edreform.com
copyright © 2010